Elyssa McClay

Elyssa "Ellie" McClay is the original name of a person who first visited the Inn in 2008, with her aunt Anne-Marie Adkisson. She was 14 years old and a native of Connecticut. She transformed into Kalli Jackson, a 22-year-old student from the University of South Carolina. Her identity was initially passed to Bryan Lewis. Her aunt became Kalli's friend Julia DiFrancesco.

As Kalli, Ellie worked as a nanny for a family that lived in the same neighborhood as her real self. After a visit to her home in South Carolina, she struck up a relationship with Julia's ex-boyfriend, Todd "T2" Jones. This was revealed after a bra of Kalli's was found in the couch cushions of Anne-Marie's home, and she admitted to bringing Todd over when the family was visiting New York City. Both Todd and Anne-Marie disapproved of the relationship, citing the actual difference in age, experience and expectations. Ellie maintained that the two were not sexually active, but asserted that even if that were the case, she had every right to make a decision for herself. She accused Todd and Anne-Marie of hypocrisy due to Todd's relationship with Hal, but Todd dismissed this by saying "sex isn't love." Ellie lamented that it was unfair that she was so free as Kalli but still had to go back to being her old self. Todd assured her she would have her whole awkward teen years, and an uncomfortable first time with an equally-inexperienced boy to look forward to.

Up until March 2009, Anne-Marie and Ellie were unable to contact the original Julia and Kalli.

Bryan described her natural appearance as "average." with long golden hair and a slender frame. As Kalli, she as a comparatively "mature-looking" woman of African-American descent.